Should you buy a rental property? Five honest questions
Five yes/no questions before buying a rental: 20–25% down + 6 months reserves? Stable income independent of the property? Willing to be a landlord (or pay 8–12% to a manager)? Know the local market? Could absorb a 30% price decline?
Direct ownership is the most common form of real estate investing for individuals. It's also the form with the highest workload, highest concentration risk, and highest tax benefits. Five honest questions stand between "I want one" and "I should buy one":
1. Down + reserves: a $300K property requires $60–75K down, $5–10K closing, and $5–10K of operating reserves. Without that cushion, one bad month spirals. 2. Stable independent income: a negative-cash-flow month is uncomfortable; one when you've also lost your job is dangerous. 3. Landlord temperament or budget: if you can't take the 11pm call, build the property manager fee into underwriting. 4. Local knowledge: out-of-state investing is doable but harder. 5. Stress test: real estate doesn't decline often, but when it does, leveraged investors can lose everything.
If five honest yes's, direct ownership probably makes sense. If not, REITs and funds give you real estate exposure without the demands.